|
|
|
Sign Up for Alerts
Just provide your email for the Latest
News!
Your personal information will be kept in strict confidence
and only used to answer your questions or update you on events.
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
 notes |
|
|
|
|
 THE EXEMPLARY PROJECT OF THE CENTER FOR
PEER
REVIEW JUSTICE
If you are aware of a hospital that
ignores safety and uses its bylaws to benefit and shield
corporate doctors and nurses and retaliates against
independent doctors please call the Exemplary Project.
If you are an independent doctor who has suffered an unjust
report to the National Practitioner's Data bank (NPDB) from
a malpractice settlement or professional review please
call the Exemplary Project.
If you have been the
subject of a Sham Peer Review, a Bad Faith Peer Review or
any abuse of the Health Care Quality Improvement Act of 1986
( HCQIA), we would like to know. We want to shine the light
on hospital fraud, clear the names of the good guys and
bring the bad guys to justice ! Call the Exemplary
Project.
Your call will be confidential and you are
protected from retaliation by the Patient Safety and Quality
Improvement Act of 2005.
info@PeerReview.org 504-621-1670
|
-
Consulting Sham Peer Review
Defense
-
spotlight
sham medical peer review
-
provide
resources for both victims of sham peer review and their legal counsel
-
work
together to bring about legislative and judicial change
-
network
to voice concerns regarding due process, confidentiality and the politics
involved in the medical professions
-
share our victories and defeats
Preamble - What we believe in!
Follow link for Peer Review Solutions!
Richard's articles, "thank you" notes and testimonials are
included in our newest website.
- "Extra" Judicial or "Extra"- legal services. Necessary
services that your lawyer does not offer The opposing side enjoys
"immunity" and as such, it takes away any advantage the Peer Reviewed Doctor
might have
- Management of the media to get the truth out
- Consulting Sham Peer Review Defense
- Legal Consulting by Center lawyers
- Negotiation
- Legal Referral Service. "The best lawyer is not the most expensive one."
Is your lawyer CPRJ Certified? Check with us for one in your
area.
- Lectures on "Physician Peer Review Abuse"
and/or State Medical Board Abuse to your organization or medical society
- Other services
LECTURES
We are available to lecture and have presentations on the following topics:
- Physician Peer Review Abuse (Sham Peer Review)
- State Medical Board Abuse
- National Practitioner Database Solutions
-
A topic of your choice.
Call The Center at 504-621-1670 or
email us for details
Educating Doctors Against Sham Peer
Review
Frequently the careers of physicians
and other medical professionals are
threatened by sudden challenges, many of
which are motivated by bad faith on the
part of hospital administrators and
other practitioners.
If you are being accused of providing
substandard care, being a "disruptive
physician" or any other claim that calls
into question your ability to practice
medicine safely, you could be facing
consequences including the following:
- Loss of
hospital privileges
- Loss of your license
- A listing in the
National Practitioner Data Bank
-
Administrative, regulatory or
criminal penalties
-
Federal health care programs
exclusion
You need an experienced team with custom strategies to guide you through each
stage of the process and stand up for
your rights. The administrative
hearings do not follow the same "due
process" rule of law that are used
in a courtroom.
Are you and your legal team experienced
in these frequently closed door
meetings? Call The Center at 504-621-1670 or
email us for details
|
Sign Up For Quick Response
From
|
TMA
Seminar in Dallas May 2012
Lots of Lectures, Vendors,
and lots of Texans to meet &
educate
posted to Facebook by
Richard Willner on
Thursday, March 15, 2012 at
3:42pm
Three U.S. Senators have asked federal health officials to
review the way state medical boards regulate the nation's
physicians.
The request was prompted by recent reports from a citizen's
watchdog group and three newspapers, including the Star Tribune,
that "highlighted disturbing failures of state medical boards to
discipline physicians," the senators said. The letter was signed
by Sens. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa; Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, and Max
Baucus, D-Montana.
In a Feb. 15 letter, the senators asked the inspector general of
the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to "evaluate
the effectiveness" of state boards and provide recommendations
on ways to protect the public from "unqualified or marginally
proficient practitioners."
Among their concerns, the senators noted that the number of
serious disciplinary actions imposed on doctors by state medical
boards was 20 percent lower in 2010 than in 2004.
In a Star Tribune investigation of the Minnesota Board of
Medical Practice, it was revealed that at least 46 Minnesota
doctors escaped board discipline after authorities in other
states took action against their licenses for such missteps as
committing crimes, patient care errors or having sexual or
inappropriate relationships with patients.
The Star Tribune's report, published earlier this month, also
showed that the board never disciplined more than half of the 74
doctors who lost their privileges to work in Minnesota hospitals
and clinics over the past decade.
The board, which oversees 20,000 physicians, said its record
reflects a philosophy of correcting problems rather than
punishing practitioners.
A Minnesota legislative commission has recommended that the
medical board continue in its current form. However, Rep. Mary
Kiffmeyer, R-Big Lake, the commission chairwoman, said the
commission plans to meet with board officials at a 9 a.m. public
hearing Friday at the State Office Building to talk about
questions raised by the Star Tribune investigation.
"In light of the new information, we want to take another look,"
Kiffmeyer said. "We want to give them an opportunity to defend
themselves and [give the commission] an opportunity to
reconsider what they want to do. ... This is really about
protecting the public and not protecting the doctors."
|
|
 Gearing
Up for a National
PR Blitz
We now have
Members actively Involved to Take your Queries and Defend our
Profession
Dallas,
Austin, Houston, New York City, Lincoln IL, Chicago, Miami FL,
Boca Raton, Seattle, San Francisco, Las Vegas, San Diego,
Boulder CO, New Orleans,
Atlanta, Birmingham, Memphis, Gadsden AL, Lexington, New Haven, Boston,
Little Rock, Great Falls MN, ...
more being added as commitments continue lining up
We have 3
dedicated servers with redundant backups to handle bandwidth,
send and receive large attachments & faxes, and our huge database
collection. Developing open-source blogs, many private member groups
on facebook to address the different facets by locale,
profession, and discrimination cause. |
Richard Willner comments on the Health Care Quality
Improvement Act (HCQIA) and on the
National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB), Washington, DC. Yes, he
informs the Democratic leadership also!
|
TERRIFYING RESULTS OF "PHYSICIAN PEER REVIEW
FRAUD"
( SHAM PEER REVIEW)
by Richard Willner, CEO
The Center for Peer Review Justice
Regarding "Suspended Physician's Hearing Put
on Hold" ( AMNews ): The concept of a patent's alleged "imminent
danger" coupled with legal immunities guaranteed by the federal
Health Care Quality Improvement Act of 1986 ( "HCQIA") and
similar state laws, followed by the Courts' reluctance it second
guess physicians' "professional" opinions, can lead to
terrifying results for the physician under fire. Both medical
institutions ( e.g. hospitals) and state medical boards can play
the "summary suspension" trump card on a hapless victim without
fear of significant legal liability or effective judicial
review. The physician being so attacked has little recourse, and
he or she may suffer terrible and irreparable monetary loss,
even if demonstrably "not guilty".
(read more)
(follow up on this particular case -
Gil N. Mileikowsky, MD)
This is America!! Why no Justice for Physicians and Surgeons?
|
Physician Brownouts and Hospital Liability
Shifting Up Due to Obama Care
by Richard Willner, CEO
The Center for Peer Review Justice
I am not shocked to see such a sharp uptick in “Physician
Brownout’ sham peer review cases.
Physician Brownout is a term Richard Willner coined to describe a special
kind of peer review or professional retaliation which involves
liability shifting for nursing error or any of a number of
events where a hospitals has liability for its agents.
“After 11 years and hundreds of cases, you get to be a bit of an
epidemiologist on sham peer review. (read more)
|
Health Care Fraud and Accrual Based Accounting
by Richard Willner, CEO
The Center for Peer Review Justice
http://www.goldcoastchronicle.com/politics/health-care-fraud-use-accrual-based-accounting/
May 18, 2011
Health care fraud is a double entry system of accounting. We
must discipline our thinking to reflect that of the accountant
and lawyer so engaged in order to find the crooks and gather
evidence of their misdeeds.
It is pointless to completely focus on the all too necessary
whining and sniveling and cross examination of our self worth
that the system forces us to do. We eventually only bail water
into our own boats and vomit on our friends.
Every time you hear about sham peer review of independent
doctors, ask yourself what is on the credit side of each
equation. Richard Willner is the chief epidemiologist of this.
Is it in the thousands?
(read more)
|
Sham Peer Review and Increased Physician Suicide Risk
by Richard Willner
Various stressors have been correlated to physician suicide,
including: personal, financial, and profession. Anyone who has
been under pressure from a legitimate review process will
readily tell you that it can be stressful. If the review is a
sham, the stressful nature of the review increases dramatically.
(read
more)
|
Availability of Information to Patients as an
Offset to Sham Peer Review
by Richard Willner
The present scheme for providing information to patients that
would presumably allow patients to minimize their own risks
involving the treatment by various doctors is not perfect, to
say the very least. Currently, state licensure boards and other
disciplinary bodies regulate the flow of physician quality
parameters.
(read more)
|
26 Oct – Nashville
- The
Board of Directors is proud to announce
that Dr. Richard Willner, is the
Semmelweis Society International “Clean
Hands Award” recipient for 2010.
Tireless Advocate
 Civil
litigation is not for everyone, but Dr.
Willner has successfully kept physicians
employed – even when facing seemingly
hopeless odds.
“Litigation is
very time-consuming. One is out of the
operating room for prolonged periods of
time, it costs a fortune and the rate of
success is very poor,” says Willner.
In one case, Dr.
Willner’s work led to the resignation of
an entire State Podiatric Medical Board.
Among the many
‘thank you’ letters are examples of
gratitude for expunging records,
reinstated licenses, and prevented data
banking – cases that included a
neurologist subjected to a criminal
trial. Thanks to Dr. Willner, his
medical license was reinstated.
Dr. Willner
applies a sound approach to prevent Data
Banking by counseling physicians labeled
as “disruptive” and getting them back
into practice within the specified time
limits. In extreme cases, he has had
cases expunged entirely.
SSI commends Dr.
Willner for untold hours of mentoring
and counseling. His body of work
attests to his love of medicine and deep
admiration for honorable physicians.
For more
information about Dr. Willner, contact
us:
|
|
Announcing the honoree of the Center for Peer
Review Justice Award
Healthcare Reporter of the Year
Steve Twedt
of the Pittsburg Post Gazette
"The Cost of
Courage" |
How To
Protect Physician Whistleblower Patient
Advocates from Retaliation
Sign Up for Alerts
Just provide your email for the Latest
News!
Your personal information will be kept in strict confidence
and only used to answer your questions or update you on events.
|
Specialty: Consulting Sham Peer Review
Defense
|
CPRJ: Development of PR and Media
Department
The
CPRJ began after the crusade to prove
the innocence of a single physician. In
2000, a podiatrist named Brian Gale
worked for the head of the North Dakota
Podiatry Board, and they subsequently
had a falling out. Brian then began
working for a group called Bismarck,
which was in direct competition to his
previous employer, the head of the
board. After this move, he began being
terrorized by the Podiatric Board.
After filing suit, he twice lose in the
Court of Appeals, then at the North
Dakota Supreme Court.
In
despair, and without any further avenues
to pursue, he wrote a letter to fellow
members of the profession and asked for
their help. In stepped his savior, Dr.
Richard Willner. Dr. Willner was
curious as to how a physician with 4
years of residency training, the longest
available residency for podiatrists,
could possibly be such a "bad doctor"
Of note, Dr. Gale had not a single
malpractice suit. Brian Gale sent him
29 pounds of documents regarding his
case, and Dr. Willner poured through
these documents giving each his undivided
attention.
At
this time, the CPRJ initiated a public
relations and media firm that became so
powerful, it salvaged Dr. Gale's
professional reputation, reinstated him
in podiatric medicine, and resulted in
the resignation of ALL the members of
the North Dakota Board of Podiatric
Medicine. As time passed, this public
relations firm has continued to grow and
become more influential. Through the
utilization of technology and multiple
databases, the CPRJ has been essential
in highlighting problems with sham peer
review and exposing those individuals
who participate in this practice. These
databases include healthcare writers of
every national newspaper in the United
States, many thousands of healthcare
blogs, and every major television
reporter covering healthcare stories.
The CPRJ has recently partnered with women's
groups to specifically crusade for women
faced with disparities in the medical
workplace. These women's groups
include political advocacy groups, women's blogs, individuals focused on
women's studies in universities, and
women politicians. The database formed
with these partnerships includes
demographic data which is maintained by
a battery of committed volunteers
nationwide.
The CPRJ database is used in the plight for
physician justice. The headquarters are
located in Dallas, Texas, but this
information is backed up in several
states. With 11 years under its belt,
the CPRJ has become exponentially more
powerful than it was even in the
beginning years of 2000. From the
beginning, the CPRJ has sustained public
relations for greater than a year for
those affected. Physicians involved in
sham peer review can finally even the
playing field and have the chance to
stand up for what they believe in: a
true and just system.
CPRJ has partnered with the fastest
growing medical society, the America's
Medical Society,
www.AmericasMedicalSociety.com , to
extend it's reach to Medical doctors,
Osteopaths,
Podiatrists, Nurses, Physician therapists,
Occupational Therapists, Pharmacists, etc
|
Slave Labor and Liability?
The Effect of EMTALA on Physicians
|
Where do the
complaints come from?
Medical Tuesday Network
Physicians, Professional and
Information Technology Communities
Networking to Restore Accountability in HealthCare & Medical Practice
Have you Joined?
|
Blogs being developed for specific arenas
|
|
Conferences
- More TBA
Dr Richard Willner,
Faculty member in Seattle
Conference
Thrive - Not JUST Survive III:
"Shark
Proof Your Practice"
Agenda from San Antonio Conference
Thrive - Not JUST Survive II:
"Shark
Proof Your Practice" |
Dr Willner quoted or featured in
the Media
(click on link to read article)
|
|
Should " DUE PROCESS RIGHTS "
be part of hospital peer review?
By Judge Scott E. Segall and William Pearl, MD
-
....There is no federal statute that
requires peer review committees to observe due process, which the Supreme Court
has defined as giving written notice of the actions contemplated, convening a hearing, allowing both sides to present evidence at the hearing,
and having an independent adjudicator
... Because the HCQIA
mandates the reporting of disciplinary actions of peer review committees to
the National Practitioner Data Bank, such a report could harm a physician's
career throughout the nation
... Additionally,
there is no requirement that the physician be given notice and an opportunity to
be heard, and there is no requirement that members of the peer review
committee be unbiased. The HCQIA recommends that the physician should get
notice of the allegations, time to prepare for a hearing, a list of witnesses,
the right to legal counsel, and an impartial fact finder.
... However, the act
concludes "A professional review body's failure to meet the conditions
described in this subsection shall not, in itself, constitute failure to meet
the standards of this act)."
This
failure of the HCQIA to require due process calls into question the fundamental
fairness of the medical peer review system..
...The purpose of requiring due
process is to ensure that the actions taken are not arbitrary, capricious, or
unreasonable. Where there is no due process, the system invites abuse
...Peer review in its current form
fails to protect an investigated physician from committee members having an
economic or personal bias. Economic bias occurs when a committee member has a
financial interest in the outcome.
...Personal bias is inevitable when
coworkers judge each other. Some people are very likable, and others illuminate
the room by their absence.
...Federal law prohibits a federal
judge from hearing cases in which his impartiality might reasonably be
questioned or in which he has a financial interest (11). The same standards
should apply to member of a peer review committee. The potential for abuse when
these suggested procedures are not followed would indicate the need for
mandatory due process.
...The effects of an adverse peer
review decision are no longer limited to the relationship between a physician
and a hospital. The decision becomes part of the National Practitioner Data
Bank. Medical peer review must provide physicians the protections
of due process.
These are excerpts...for
Full Article follow Link
|
What
to do when your lawyer
did not give you the success he implied
6/4/2004 -
JFK hospital reinstates high-risk heart surgeon
Dr. Lancelot "Lance" Lester, a top Palm Beach County heart
surgeon who was suspended last summer by JFK Medical Center over "quality of
care" issues, has been reinstated by the hospital.
Lester, who specializes in treating high-risk patients, is expected to be back
in the operating room within a few weeks, hospital spokeswoman Madelyn
Passarella said Thursday.
 Plaintiff
wins Case against Databank!!!
Cuthbert O Simpkins, MD
pages 1-7
"JOHN DOE, MD" V. DATABANK WIN
EMAIL
LEGAL@PEERREVIEW.ORG FOR DETAILS
A
PEER REVIEW WIN!!!
- David M
Odom, MD - Alaska
OTHER PEER REVIEW WINS !!!!!
PLEASE E-MAIL
LEGAL@PEERREVIEW.ORG
OR CALL 504-621-1670
Probing legal questions
- you need to ask when charges are brought against you
- we will help you find answers at the Center for Peer Review Justice
- Consulting Sham Peer Review Defense
Are "TIME", "NEWSWEEK" and
"USA TODAY" Going To Be
Investigating ....
Hospital Peer
Review Issues |
What Others are Saying about the
Center
We do not
showcase our wins as people deserve their privacy. However,
I do show their "Thank you notes" with their initials
with their permission.
-
From: Pastor Alvin
J. Jackson,
Dear Dr. Willner,
I along with the members of the First Emmanuel Baptist
Church located at 1301 Solon Street, Gretna, Louisiana would
like to take this opportunity to thank you for your personal
concern for patients starting up the Diabetic Black American
Outreach Program. The valuable information you provided
regarding Diabetes and the Black community did indeed help
answer many questions that the members had. In many
instances for those in attendance ths questions answered and
information you provided were the first step in recognizing
and dealing with the serious problem of Diabetes. This
outreach program already has proven to be very successful.
In the short period of time it has reached Black at the
following churches: Secondary Highway Baptist Church,
Regular Baptist Church, St. Stephens Baptist Church.
So again, I would like to thank you for doing something that
has never been done before. You have stretched out your
hands to a community, and race or people that had little
knowledge of a very serious problem affecting them. The
implementation of the Diabetic Black American Outreach
Program will help many of those that would not otherwise
seek help or answers to many of their questions or concerns.
Sincerely,
Rev. Alvin J. Jackson
-
From: "LL"
To: Richard W. <info@peerreview.org>
Sent: Sunday, December 18, 2011 12:22 PM
Subject: Bless you!!!
So Richard; how do I express my "dripping" praise for you?
Well, I am now wearing 3 winter jackets so I can perspire to
the point of dripping gallons of sweat as a symbolic
gesture. You are very generous and I appreciate from the
heart what you are doing.
Will be in touch.
Enjoy your game as well. The Jets need to run the table I
think at this point to get the last Wild Card spot.
Lou
-
Sent: Tuesday,
November 15, 2011 12:48 PM
Subject: thank
you
Rich,
Just under a year ago, I was in danger of losing my career.
I was thrown into an experience which was horrifying,
stressful, expensive, and downright degrading. I was being
attacked. When I first spoke with you, I was afraid you
would think I was a horrible person (as those shammers would
have one believe.)
You listened and saw the truth and helped me; you stuck with
me and we ended up victorious. I wanted to thank you for all
your help. that sounds so trite in comparison to all you did
for me. You truly are a saint. You even took the time to
speak with me late at night when I would call terrified
about keeping my career. You are intelligent, committed,
energetic, and innovative; and you have many good friends in
many places. You are dedicated to your work and to doing the
right thing whatever it takes. I commend you.
You are probably responsible for many lives being saved that
you don't even know of. Why? Because you save the practices
of those physicians who are the good ones, who get wrongly
accused by the bad ones. You really should be sainted or
knighted or something like that. Words do not do justice to
express my heartfelt appreciation to you!
Sincerely,
L.G., MD
-
Sent: Monday, November 7, 2011 2:52 PM
Dr. Willner,
I just want to express my heart felt gratitude towards you.
I truly believe God put you in my life as a guardian angel.
When I first contacted you, I felt relieved just to have
someone to talk to who believed in me and offered me
guidance throughout this whole process. I had no idea what a
huge role you would play in helping me get my license.
Throughout the months, I have not always known exactly what
your plans would be or what you were doing behind the
scenes, but now in looking back, it all makes sense. I know
I say this a lot, but I definitely feel as though you were
made for doing what you do. You have the knowledge and
experience to correct the wrongs of the medical field, but
above all, you have the heart. You have a heart of gold and
truly care about people, and that is why you are so
successful.
The past few weeks leading up to the medical board hearing
were so stressful and I could not have gotten through it
without you. I can never express enough to you my gratitude
for you driving all the way down here to be at my side
during the hearing. Without you, I would not have a license
or a career in medicine. You have made a friend for life.
Please let me know if there is anything I can ever do for
you...
KMS, MD
-
From: KS
To: Richard Willner <info@peerreview.org>
Sent: Monday, May 2, 2011 6:03 PM
Subject: Dear Richard,
Thank you for all your hard work. I know you have your heart
and soul in what you do. It is clear to me you give
everything a great deal of thought and you are always
working on your cases, day and night. I know what you do
doesn't happen without a tremendous amount of caring as well
as a keen intelligence. I have been so grateful you have
been there for me so many time. It is very overwhelming
going through all the changes and to work through all the
uncertainty it brings to one's life. I am confident if there
is anyone who can help me it is you. My very best to you for
your dedication and unyielding desire to help those of us
who find ourselves in what feels like an insurmountably
array of difficulties that come with a scam peer review.
KS
in Massachusetts
-
Sent: Mon, October 11, 2010
12:16:43 PM
Subject: Thank you
Dr. Willner,
Thank you for your hard work and invaluable insights with regard to handling
disciplinary matters with the medical board. Your approach to handling these
matters helped avoid a deportation because the lack of due process protections
in medical board matters may frustrate favorable resolution through the
adversarial legal processes available to physicians.
WPR
-
A letter from the
Hospital following a killer sham?
That is a
first. Who would believe it?
Sent: Wednesday, December 12, 2007
5:46:44 AM
Subject: Happy Holidays!!
Dear Rich, Our spirits were raised today when we read
the APOLOGY letter from our old hospital. It has been
expensive, stressful, and educational for myself and my
family to survive the ordeals begun a year ago. Thanks
for your ongoing support and for always being there for us.
Talking to you first prevented me from doing or saying the
wrong thing....our surgeons' angel!! Thanks for everything!!
T.H, DO, FACOOG
-
Dr. Richard
Willner
Center for Peer
Review Justice
December 10,
2007
Dear Rich,
Until recently,
I had never known the real depths of
despair. As an individual who has
desired to be a physician from a
very young age, witnessing
first-hand the near destruction of
my career was tantamount to being
annihilated as a person. Your
perseverance to rectify my situation
and to seek-out the hidden method to
unravel and thus resolve the dilemma
of my career is nothing but
phenomenal. The drive with which
you approached the case and your
unyielding desire to see this
“wrong” put to “right” is
remarkable. Few individuals have
the motivation to help anyone in a
situation such as this, yet you
assisted me although I was
previously unknown to you. Quickly,
you established a method to salvage
my career. You did that for me as
well as many others. I can not
thank you enough for the work that
you have accomplished.
If I could
reward you the Nobel Prize for
humanitarianism… I would do so.
There are many unsung heroes in this
world. You are definitely one of
them. A civil rights activist of
sorts…. Leading the fight for those
unjustly accused who have committed
no crime except that of desiring
quality. Unfortunately, the medical
community has named the outspoken
disruptive. Ironic, I think, in a
land where speech is to be free. Is
it really free if it costs one
his/her career? I think not.
I applaud your
efforts and those of your hidden
“band of brothers” who guide you
along the way.
May you
continue to persevere for those of
our medical family who are unjustly
persecuted.
Please continue
your grass-roots efforts to inform
the uninformed of the misnomer
assigned to the phrase peer review.
With heart-felt
gratitude,
-
December 5,
2007 6:07:10 AM
Subject: RE:
Orlando Medical News
Fascinating, Rich.
I have to say, when I read this,
I felt a deep sense of pride &
privilege. I wish my Mom had
been alive to know what you¢re
doing. She was like that; she'd
stand up, and defend others,
the weak, and those who've been
given a raw deal. You ended up
helping many, many others with
their careers. This is not only
cool, it¢s great. I¢m really
impressed at the position you've
established here. You¢re a
f***** ghost buster!
B. B.
-
December 2007 - Follow Link for
Orlando
Medical News Article
- Sent: Tuesday, October 30, 2007 5:36:18 PM
Subject: LOUISIANA MEDICAL NEWS
DATE: October 30, 2007
TO: Richard
Willner, DPM
RE:
LOUISIANA MEDICAL NEWS
(follow link
for full article)
Rich:
Congratulations! This is an excellent article. I
applaud your accomplishments, and wish you
continued success in the battle against the
'Whores of Healthcare'.
Sincerely,
M. P., M.D.
Dr. Richard B. Willner’s
crusade began seven years ago (2000) with an e-mail. In it,
Dr. Brian Gale described his battle
with the North Dakota Board of Podiatric Medical
Examiners. Gale maintained the dispute began when he
left another doctor’s practice to begin his own. That
doctor sued Gale, and the board filed disciplinary
charges against Gale. The resulting ordeal was at the
eight-year mark when Willner got involved. By that time,
Gale had run through seven attorneys and burned through
more than $500,000 in legal fees, only to lose at the
state Supreme Court.
|
| Dr. Richard Willner |
“I asked him to send me a copy of the source
documents,” Willner said. “He sent me 29 pounds worth. I
went through them. I saw he was 100 percent truthful,
and I did not understand how a state board could
terrorize a licensee. I volunteered to help him.” Three
years later, every board member had resigned from the
North Dakota board, Willner said.
“You’ve got a guy, a middle-aged man who said, ‘You
know, I don’t really want to do another hammer toe
surgery again. I’ve had enough,’” Willner said. “I want
to do something better. I want to do something dynamic.”
He founded The Center for Peer Review Justice Inc. The
center now has offices in Kenner and Dallas. Eventually
Willner retired as a podiatrist.
Source: Ted Griggs,
Louisiana Medical News
[10/25/07] |
-
September 24, 2007 7:19:29 PM
Subject: Re: Holiday Season
|
Rich,
I too want to wish you and your
family the happiest of holidays! I
am still hopeful that all of your
efforts will help to salvage the
career my husband has worked so hard
for, literally giving up everything
to dedicate himself to the care of
his patients. It is heartbreaking to
watch such a truly gifted surgeon,
who has made such a profound
difference in the lives of so many,
be literally robbed of his
livelihood and his ability to
provide for his own family --
unjustly, by others who feel
threatened by his skill and
compassion. For literally five years
now I have watched the man I love
suffer in a way I never knew
possible...the collateral damage is
unfathomable.
If it weren't for your ongoing
encouragement and support, I don't
know what might have happened... you
continue to be his beacon of light
leading him out of the darkness. I
too will never forget you and will
forever be grateful for all that you
have and continue to do to help him!
You are an angel of mercy sent from
heaven above to fight for the
downtrodden when they have lost the
will to fight for themselves. Words
cannot express the gratitude I feel
for all the support you continue to
provide!
Happy Hanukkah, Merry Christmas and
Happy New Year!
Pam
|
Tuesday, September 18, 2007
Richard all of you will be recognized for your good deeds.
Since experiencing the process first hand the world seems a
much more complex place than just a few months ago. I look
around and every one is gunning for doctors. What is the
point of all this schooling, training, experience and talent
if groups want you obliterated on whim? Is this the price
of physician existence constant? vigilance, preparation, and
engagement? As an aside I remember Clarence Thomas during
his nomination hearings refer to a "lynching" Justice
Thomas has no clue what a real lynching is.
Modern organized medicine is a joke. Physicians need to
take some of that money they are throwing away and donate it
to a group that can help them where the rubber meets the
road.
The "REAL" organized medicine is the CPRJ and its think
tank.
As Yom Kippur approaches:
Gmar hatimah tovah
Baruch atah adonai
Peace, S.M., MD
Sept 17, 2007
My husband did not utilize Rich. He decided to continue it
on his own. Rich will work very hard for you. I am
familiar with the cases he has won and it's incredible
actually. Rich is relentless & an amazing individual.
Thank you and good luck. I wish you the best. I was not
prepared for the battle. It was relentless and shocking &
so very unfair. My husband was my soul mate & best friend.
He was a beautiful human being: Generous, kind, nurses
referred to him as a gift to their hospital. It's important
that you do not try to carry this all on your own. I trust
that you have a tremendous support system.
Candace (widow of obstetrician who committed suicide)
August 7, 2007
Dr. McKalip, the biggest risk to medical practice
economic viability I have never heard mentioned at the FMA,
AMA, or any county medical society meeting.
Read this excellent article (link below) and the insert
sections on peer review. As a 2 time FMA delegate who is
just beginning to get a feel for the process, I may have
simply missed resolutions on this issue. Ultimately
the biggest imminent threat to your practice economic
viability and your medical licensure comes not from
insurance companies but from your fellow physicians and
local hospital systems.
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/03299/234499.stm
The 4 part series of articles was written in 2003 and I
cannot believe I had no clue about their significance and
content. There are few if any organizations that actually
help physicians with this threat to their economic practice
viability. It is quite literally the mucormycosis of your
professional career. Like that disease it is rare, poorly
recognized, and rapidly devastating with high degree of
morbidity and mortality.
I have no financial interest in the center for peer review
justice except that I am a member.
Sam MD
April 19, 2007 7:02 PM
Subject: Re: Fw: Sham Peer Review survival
Rich, thank you for keeping me abreast and updated.
You are an Angel of Light for the professionals. A strength
during their storm, a light of hope and one who is able to
produce results in favor of the Professional.
Candace
(widow of obstetrician who committed
suicide)
Tuesday, April 17, 2007 4:25 AM
Dear Rich,
It has been a pleasure working with you. By taking your
advice, even when it seemed to go against what some attorney
and medical practice advisors told me, I am saved. Unless
you have experienced a shamming, you won't know how
isolating and anxiety producing life in the hospital
trenches can be. Your experience and knowledge were my light
and beacon. You can't cover true light with darkness.
All of the "experts" that I have had to use in my situation
did their jobs, you actually helped me stay on the correct
course. I now have many "experts" interested in your opinion
and we have been working with your advice in mind.
My husband was happy that I could call you late at night,
over weekends, multiple times when we needed to do some
problem solving. I was actually able to have some wonderful
family moments during this very rough patch, because the
Center helped me to "decompress".
Some of my colleagues, who knew I was being shammed, were
impressed by how happy and calm I was during my peer review
process. It wasn't Prozac; it was Rich. I was able to stay
positive and focused on saving my career because you helped
me maintain my confidence in myself.
My life took a different course than expected. I am on the
verge of some wonderful opportunities. It was because you
kept me strong with my head held high, that I was able to
see that there were other places to use my skills. You have
many connections to very useful and talented people. It was
wonderful to belong to this medical, professional
fraternity.
I owe you everything. I will gladly help others if I can.
Please let me know what I can do. Sham peer review is a
career - ender. Sham peer review should be stopped. It can
happen to anyone.
Sincerely,
TH, OB/GYN
Sunday, February 25, 2007 5:59 AM
Seems to me Rich, you look like my guardian angel. I can
just barely make out the halo.
OB GYN Michigan
Dec 15, 2006
Rich,
It is really quite amazing to me the degree of perseverance
you have for working on these sham peer review cases. As we
all know, some of these cases take a great deal of time to
resolve, yet you continue to look for windows of opportunity
until there is a resolution. The resolution we all seek is
to get back to work in our field of training, and nobody has
a success record that can compare to yours.
I want to thank you for your consideration and continuing
efforts, and always being available whenever I have a
question or a problem. I can't think of anyone else, in any
business, who is literally available all hours of all the
days of the week! I cannot imagine trying to negotiate this
course without your assistance.
Sincerely,
R. L., M.D.
December 2006 -
Dear Rich:
Thank you for the long
email. You ARE a beacon of light.
Absolutely! I remain
deeply saddened of the reality that physicians
are being hunted and destroyed by hostile
hospital administrators, medical boards and
peers. You are fighting a war that you
certainly will win. My heart continues to
grieve for the talented professionals who become
targets and "are driven to slaughter." You are
their light and their hope. It is wonderful to
watch your organization grow.
Candace
(widow of obstetrician who committed
suicide)
Saturday, November 04, 2006
Thanks for the encouragement Rich. I really do appreciate your
insight and perspectives relative to my situation. These have
been quite helpful. Have a great weekend even though I know
that you work continuously.
Bernie
Oct 28, 2005
I will do anything you
suggest. I am very impressed with what you have done and the people
you have surrounded yourself with. you have surrounded yourself with
reputable people and thank you for letting me even be part of this.
J.C. MD
September 2005Dear Rich,
Thanks for being a light in the darkness. Losing my license because
bad people did things in my office has been the pits. You have been
a great encouragement to me; and helped me to reach out and do the
right thing and the positive "makes a difference thing". You have
given me worthwhile and supportive advice and helped me to get
through these bad days. It has helped me to understand the people
and power plays behind the injustice.
You have helped me get to a positive outcome. I think you have a
great grasp of the games being played .I just would like you to know
that I count you among my friends. Sometimes you have to do what
creates the best outcome, not what ever comes first to mind. I was
really too mad and down to think straight.
I would recommend your consulting for anyone that gets shot down by
a very flawed system. Thank you from the bottom of my heart!
Sincerely,
Dr K.
Sunday, September 04, 2005
Dr. Willner,
I want to thank you for your support throughout my dealings with
peer review fraud since 2001. You have truly helped my family and I
survive this crime.
Your knowledge and expertise have proven to be invaluable in matters
of peer review fraud. I would strongly recommend that anyone who
thinks they may be involved in a medical staff conflict contact you
immediately. To ignore this recommendation is foolhardy, and could
mean the end of a career. Those of us who have been through these
events know. You are truly an expert, if not the only expert, in
this field.
A physician may be represented by one of the best attorneys money
can buy, but I guarantee they are still handicapped if they don't
have your support. No affiliation with any physician group (AMA, TMA,
etc.) is going to significantly help, either. Of all the money I
have spent on defending myself, I have only seen returns on the
investment in time and money I have made with you and your
organization.
In fact, I fear there is nobody who could continue the services that
you and your organization provide should anything happen to you. So,
you and your family are welcome to stay at my home anytime a
hurricane threatens Louisiana again.
I never knew such acts as peer review fraud were possible in the
U.S. Fortunately, you have been helping victims of peer review fraud
successfully fight this (type of crime) for years! Your organization
is more valuable, both to the physician and the public, than the
AMA.
Sincerely,
R. M.D.
Chief, Dept. of Surgery-
Diplomate, American Board of Surgery
All of us who are reasonable and concerned about peer review
know of Rich's abilities and dedication. He has a vast amount of
experience in this area as well as connections and a sound fund of
knowledge. We need him and physicians who have been shammed need
him.
MD JD
"I think we need to have Rich Willner involved in the US Congressional hearings. He would bring a
wealth of experience in the trenches and has a database of numerous
cases. He also could give a more broad perspective than most of our
members."
Bill (Chairman) 3-31-05
Lawrence Huntoon, MD, PhD, Neurologist, Editor of the AAPS
Journal
Comment about Dr Willner August 2004You are unique.
Lawyers are not unique.
When people encounter something
or someone unique, they tend to shy
away from him or it, not knowing what
to make of it. Such is the curse of
greatness and uniqueness.
M any people initially thought Einstein was a hopeless
idiot.
He was different.
Ugly attitudes is like flak.
You know you
are flying over the target when you start
to see flak all around you.
Smile, you're
the one in the plane with the bombs.
No you wouldn't do anything else.
I know you better than that.
You really like what you do, and you do
it well.
Whether idiots recognize that or not
doesn't matter.
Remember, they are the idiots.
And, I appreciate your methods.
When you are outnumbered and outgunned, and there is nothing fair about
the playing field, the only option is "under the radar," stealth,
"guerilla warfare."
Larry
by J.
Matthews , MD
Richard Willner is clearly the front runner in
the area of Advocacy in the Peer Review Arena.
This is an area where the Peer Review Organizations enjoy an incredible
shield of Immunity which insulates them from having grievances addressed
in a legal arena.
These are human Beings making
decisions on issues that often relate to personality, professional
relationships, often secret, personal agendas, market shares, styles of
practice, life styles, race, religion and many other things that should
not be part of the peer review process.
Richard Willner has mastered the area of Extra Legal Methods to address
the Peer Review Organizations. How do you Shine a Light on things that
these Boards and Committees have done. They do not like the negative
publicity that results when their mistakes and often corruption is made
public.
Advocacy costs money. One should not expect it to be free. People who
promote things deserve to be compensated. That is whether they are
advocating as a Lobbyist, or preparing an advertising campaign for a
product or your practice. Richard Willner acts as a personal advocate for
individuals to bring their case to light, or possibly to restore a
reputation that has been trashed.
There are not many people who do what Richard Willner does.
Where
would you begin to find someone with his skills or even to know that
someone with his skills exists when you need them. Certainly the best place to tell people about yourself and
your services is anywhere that you are explaining what has happen need to
others.
You may not like the fact that there is someone
there advocating for people who have gotten shafted...but he has been
successful because you know he is there.
Richard WILLNER
is a Master of the Extra Legal Approach to Defense against Administrative
Injustice. You should be thankful that there is someone that is there to
help you when you need him
I think it is a major accomplishment - i.e. it is
extremely difficult, if not impossible, in most cases, for a prophet to be recognized in his own town (comes from the
New Testament).
Justice and fairness that is dependent on people and not the rule of law
is a very tenuous thing. People come and go.
Lawrence Huntoon, MD, PhD
Hi, The
widow of a physician driven to suicide told me of your Center. I am
thrilled, as I am now unemployed and unemployable as a result of
character assassination and State Board malice.
I will call you Monday for more information and to join, but wanted to
send this after reading your web site, to let you know that you are a
beacon in the wilderness, a light of reassurance and a comfort simply by
being there.
I cannot tell you how eager I am to get involved, to join you, and to
plead for your help.
Rick H.
11/08/04
Dear Rich,
Thank you for enrolling me in the CPRJ's physician education
center. The volume of information contained in the program
was impressive. It was very educational and enlightening to
review the sixty landmark legal cases that involved and went
against "disruptive" physicians. I was floored by the case
summary suspensions and the catastrophic consequences they
cause. Most fascinating was how there seemed to be an
automatic presumption of psychiatric of substance abuse
problems in the physicians accused.
As physicians we deal with out peers as our " colleagues"
and assume they will understand our behavior. I now realize,
with the help your program and ability to effectively
communicate this information, that physicians must review
the peer review process as a legal one and not "grand
rounds". It is so important that physicians understand the
meaning of the work" disruptive" and how nurses and other
hospital staff apply it to our behavior with almost complete
immunity.
Your program is complete and thorough in every way and I am
sure it is in no small part due to your passion for your
job. You are able to motivating and demanding or your
physicians, but in a funny and dynamic way. Most
importantly, I am certain that this program can improve
performance and patient care.
As CEO of the CPRJ you show a unique passion and attention
to physicians needs which makes a winning combination.
Again, thank you so much for the hard work you have done for
me and all of CPRJ's clients.
Medical Forum Post
July 2003
Comments sent by California General
and Neurosurgeon - 7/22/04
- "My thanks to Dr. Willner for taking so
much time to speak with me. I plan to inform my attorney that I would like
to obtain advice from your organization in order to put a stop to S.M.
Hospital from their repetitive career assassinations. They have their own
HMO, and if you do not "belong" to the chosen group then you are a target.
I've been threatened directly by the administrator to join their group or
he'll "drive me out of town." They also have one particular physician who
has sold his soul to S.M. Hospital and readily criticizes any and
all individuals whom he just does not like. The S.M. Hospital also has a
surgeon who is one of their HMO docs who is used to ruin the "outside"
surgeons....Any help would be greatly appreciated. I have enjoyed a
stellar career in surgery and have an impeccable reputation in community.
BUT, the hospital and their paid whores have tarnished it."
5/12/04 -
"To
Whom it May Concern:
I am writing this to commend Richard Willner, president of the Center for
Peer Review Justice, Inc. In a very short period of time, he developed a plan and
approach that saved my professional career. If I had taken the approach
that I had in mind, I would have undeservedly though undoubtedly lost my
hospital privileges. Due to what I experienced of Richard Willner’s
passion, dedication, creativity, and keen intelligence - I recommend him to
all physicians in all the varieties and all stages of trouble that we can
find ourselves in. If Harriet Tubman can be called the Moses of African
Slaves, I think it is appropriate to call Richard Willner the Moses of
beleaguered physicians."
Sincerely, Annie Bukacek MD
The Center for Peer Review Justice
quoted as a source by the
AMA
"Your
accomplishments on defending your clients is more than remarkable. It's
miraculous. But I know DAMN well it is the result of hard work, gritty
intelligence on your part and a creativity that defies your toughest
adversaries. Rich, they didn't know what they were up against...YOU.
I'm so
proud of you I could shake you by your shoulders and give you a hug."
Dr Mike
Rosenblatt
Dear Dr.
Willner,
Thank you for
listening to me and trying to help me. You are a very good
person, honest, sincere, trust worthy, over all a person who
really cares and says and does what is
practical/real/helping with open heart...no amount of money
can do that....I am so much grateful I met you and you are
helping me.
Thank you DOC....
You are one of a kind...
R.M. MD
June 6, 2004 - " Richard is my
hero." R.A, MD, JD
Author: Lydia H Grotti, MD, FCCP
Subject: Richard Willner and the Center for Peer Review Justice
Thank God for Richard Willner!
When I was at my lowest point in my
ongoing battle for the right to work in the field of my dreams,
that for which I trained for 6 years and in which I am board
certified, a voice came to me over the phone, telling me that I
am not alone in this farce that is called "disciplinary action
by the Board" or "peer review". He got me in touch with others
whom I could support and who could support me.
I was given renewed hope and will stand
tall for what is right and speak out for what is wrong. I will
remain a proponent of the patient's (and their surrogates')
right to make their own decision about their End of Life Care
and of the physician's duty to abide by that decision. I will
also remain a proponent of a patient's right to a dignified and
comfortable death, without fear, anxiety and/or pain. That is
the law and I followed the law, despite accusations to the
contrary.
With the support of the Center, Richard
Willner and my lawyers, I am confident that justice (or some
semblance thereof) will prevail. If my accusers win, Critical
Care, End of Life Care (including Hospice Care) will be set back
decades and patients will once again SUFFER death.
(http://aaps.forums.practicenotes.com/forums/Index.cfm?Message_ID=60097
"I admire your diligence and commitment to this very
important area. While you may not receive the thanks you obviously
deserve, I am certain that there is many a health professional who
has benefited from your dedication.
One day, all of us that are committed to this very important issue
where medicine and law converge will celebrate HCQIA's being
amended to mandate constitutional due process and move the burden
of persuasion from the physicians to the Hospitals. We are only
one Supreme Court case away.
Keep up the good work.
South Carolina Lawyer
(name available upon request)
Remember, great is your reward in heaven"
Sept 25, 2003 Post to Forum -
"The director of
the Sham Peer Review Organization, actually a podiatrist, has demonstrated
absolutely enormous accomplishments that are now changing the very face of
MD, DO, DDS and DPM peer review!"
Sept 26, 2003 Post to Forum
- "If
you are ever unfortunate enough to be exposed to a peer review situation,
you will thank God every day for the work and accomplishments of Richard
Willner."
05/03/03
J. Swift
Before Rich got involved there was a media blackout on sham
peer review. HIPPA is not much different.
Now people are beginning to realize that institutional peer
review is another name for corporate pseudoscience and mis-accounting
practices. The future holds great promise for the Center and
its sincere and indefatigable founder, Rich Willner. I am
glad to be his friend. I can count on one hand how many
people i have met in life that have the same level of
commitment to a just and noble cause.
05/03/03
L. R. Bailey MD
I must agree with Dr. Snioff
(see below) about Rich and the CPRJ. Sadly
many of the lessons that are taught, there always seemed to
be something learned the hard way by those who refuse to
listen. It is difficult for physicians who are accustomed to
solving problems to accept that some problems cannot be
"solved". Society thinks that everything that everything can
be settled in court. That just absolutely is not true and
the courts seem to make things worse and definitely more
expensive!! If you are having peer review problems, listen
to Rich and pay lip service to the attorneys.
03/19/03
I wanted to comment about how invaluable is the Center for
Peer Review Justice(CPRJ).
In June 2000 the following dubious "review" by physicians,
non of whom were in my specialty, my employment was
terminated and my career amputated. There was little advice
of information anywhere. I was stunned and bewildered.
Some months later I became aware of Dr. Richard Willner and
then the fledging Center for Peer Review Justice. Rich had
become involved in the case or Dr. Brian Gale, a podiatrist
in North Dakota, and Rich was just beginning to learn the
ropes.
Since then, he has devoted himself tirelessly, and at great
personal cost, to those unjustly wronged. As far as i am
aware, he has never refused advice or assistance, even
though he did this without payment. Over the years, Rich has
developed foremost knowledge asnd expertise of the whole
peer review process. I believe that he has become aware of
over 2,300 cases in the last three years, where the motives
ad performance of a peer review have malice, bias and
incompetence.
At present, the CPRJ has an impressive website (PeerReview.org),
with an expanding list of cases and opinions, as well as a
panel of legal experts who have extensive experience in
representing physicians who are victims of a sham peer
review. There is an evolving modus operandi on how to mount
a defense, as well as a campaign to expose the abuse of peer
review to a wide public.
I would urge any physician who is a victim of such abuse to
contact Rich at info@peerreview.org for assistance. I would
also urge any organization, such as the AAPS, to support the
Center financially, as Rich cannot continue to bear the cost
from his own pocket.
Clive Sinoff
Date: February 01, 2002 11:54 PM
Author: Brian Gale (brian@BrianGale.com )
Subject: I have the scars of
a Sham Peer Review
I have been fighting a battle since 1993. Some say they would have
given up a long time ago. Others say I'm lucky that I still have my
home and my clinic although payments on everything are always late.
I've also been told that I'm lucky I've only spent about $500k or so
even though it translates into several million down the road.
Thanks to Rich Willner and a few other friends and relatives I'm
still alive and kicking. There are some extremely important rules
about going up against hospitals and boards; the faster someone
accepts them as fact, the better chance they have of prevailing.
Rich Willner is without a doubt the number one expert in the United
States on this subject. I know that's saying a lot but I have spent
hundreds of hours speaking to him and we have exchanged somewhere in
the range of thousands of emails.
He reads every case he can get his hands on and understands how the
evil system works. Most of our conversations lately have been about
people who are spending hundreds of thousands on lawyers who don't
have a clue what they're doing. When a lawyer calls Rich, Rich can
give them the legal cases they need to try to make a difference.
Rich is worth his weight in gold and then some when it comes to
someone who has been abused as some of us have. Just take a look at
www.briangale.com. The web site was Rich's idea. At first my wife
and I really hesitated because I was in the process of cashing in my
entire retirement (not that it was that big) as well as our kids
colleges savings, just to be able to pay some bills. Reluctantly we
went along with it and it has been given us a tremendous return on
our very small investment.
The web site literally neutralized a lot of the
"evil doers" as
President Bush calls them. There is no time to fight back and get on
the offensive because all of the shammed person's time is spent on
the defensive side.
I spent 8 years and now I have finally managed to have almost all of
the members of our state board that shammed me replaced. I did this
only with the help of Rich Willner.
For those of you who read this and are in a similar predicament;
join the Center for Peer Review Justice. It was the ONLY thing I did
in the past 8 years that saved me.
I'm not out of this mess yet but I'm in better shape now than I have
ever been. I understand the system and the players. Now I tell my
lawyer what he needs to do and how to handle things after Rich and I
have extensive discussions about it. My lawyer is still involved and
has the final say about what he will and won't do and everything
that is done is legal; whether the lawyer(s) know about it or not.
These people (shammers) take very little time to do one thing that
creates years of pain, suffering and nightmares for us and our
families. Depression is a given for all of us. At times we are
paralyzed emotionally and physically so we are too weak to fight
back. We try to hold our families together because they are the most
precious commodity we have and that takes so much time and energy
that there is nothing left.
Rich Willner has given me hope. He has been the "equalizer" for me.
Why did he get involved? Because he loves a challenge and he
couldn't believe that the things I posted publicly on another forum
could be true. When he did his own investigation a few years ago, he
began opening up the world of sham peer review.
As bad as things are and have been I still have many things to be
thankful for. I am alive, I have my health. For some reason I still
have my wife (many leave for obvious reasons) and little girls too.
Many of us who have been shammed are not as lucky as me. If I could
take all the pain my wife has endured away and put it inside me
because of what I have been put through I would gladly take it from
her.
In simple terms the answer is networking and fighting back. Think of
it as the ultimate challenge of your life. There are no rules except
for the one's the shammers make up as they go. You have nothing to
lose because your (my) life has been destroyed professionally. Take
it on as if it becomes your only mission in life. "Take no
prisoners." You have to pull out every bit of passion you can muster
and keep pushing on.
The first step is to contact Rich AND do what he says; take his
advice. We have to begin aggressively helping each other. A huge
advantage that Rich gives us is that he can get a number of reviews
for anyone at any given time from authoritative leaders in the
specialty field of his choice. If anyone needs my help I'm
available. This is not a fight that can be won with just the lawyers
through the courts. That's what they want us to do is go through the
legal process. It doesn't cost them a penny while it breaks us and
our families.
Call me any time to talk or for advice.
Brian Gale, DPM, FACFAS 701-255-3338 clinic 701-202-1885 cellular
701-223-8841 home
(http://aaps.forums.commentary.net/forums/Index.cfm?Message_ID=54096)
Observation
by Member
Members
suggest reasonable changes
|
Web Site Links
- Organizational Sites
- America's
Medical Society our newest partner also on
- War on Doctors
- There has been a battle pursuing doctors for
years. Now it seems to be on all fronts
- Peer Review Solutions
addresses solutions for the problem
-
Medical
Student Loans - resource site
for those dealing with medical student loans
-
HCQIA - Health Care Quality Act -
Learn how it impacts your practice of medicine, and how it can be abused
-
The Disruptive Physician's Center
- Offers guidance and support to those who have
been labeled "disruptive"
-
Association of American Physicians and Surgeons
-
Electronic Frontier Foundation -
Federal Court Upholds Anonymous Speech on Internet
-
Institute for Safe Medical
Practices - follow for
discussion of medical errors
|
Defining the terms-- (more listed in
Members Only section)
-
Definition of Professional Misconduct
-
Peer Review Principals - general
concept of peer review- multi-disciplinary
-
Additional Definition of Professional Misconduct, Limited
Application
-
(CA) Background Paper on Medical Peer
Review - defines "805
report"
-
Requirements for the Dr Expert Witness
|
Legal/Judicial
- (more listed in
Members Only section)
-
Links for Legal Research - includes legal precedents
-
Heath Hippo: Quality Assurance
- US Statutes and Administrative Codes
|
Databank Lists of Medical Professionals
-(more listed in
Members Only
section)
-
Professional Misconduct and Physician Discipline
- goes back 10 years with monthly summaries (note many of the physicians on these list live and worked in many states other than NY
- over 12,000 disciplined physicians are listed)
-
Federation
of State Boards - docinfo.org
-
National Practitioner Data Baset
National Practitioner
Data Base Fact Sheet
GETTING A NEW JOB.
THERE IS A LOT OF EXTRA WORK NECESSARY TO
GET A NEW JOB AFTER A SHAM PEER REVIEW AND DATA BANKING. THE CENTER FOR PEER
REVIEW JUSTICE MIGHT BE ABLE TO HELP YOU WITH HEADHUNTING, CREDENTIALING,
DATABANK REPAIR, GETTING MALPRACTICE INSURANCE OR A LOWER RATE, ETC.
If you have been
unfairly " please call our President at
504-621-1670. Perhaps there is action that you can take.
|
-
Dr. Brian Gale
(link to his website 2002)
- podiatrist in North Dakota. It's bad news when your
competition "owns" the State Board of your specialty. A Peer Review
Justice client that has his license back and is catching up on his bills.....he
also unseated most of the state board and changed the state
statutes!
I have the scars of a sham peer review!
- Oct 17, 2006 - Jay Schindler, MD, a neurosurgeon, won a major
victory today when the Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment under HCQIA
was DENIED (as to the relevant parties) today in his federal lawsuit in
Wisconsin.
Jay is a really credible, honest and driven physician. Patient care is his
passion in life and he was frankly a victim of his own success, being
shammed only because he was more efficient and productive than his
competitors. His ouster was based essentially on a single complicated case.
He and his wife Jean have fought courageously against the powerful
defendants in his case and today it paid off. 2012 update - he moved to a
different state and has a successful practice there.
- Dr. Steven Dilsaver - Outstanding psychiatrist wishes to return to his home state of California to
practice medicine and is placed on severe probation in spite of begin licensed
in several other states and being a widely recognized researcher and author of
many journal articles in the field of psychiatry. No malpractice cases, no
criminal charges; just the stigma of admitting to a prior treatment for a
mental illness over 5 years ago.
-
Dr. Philip J Leonard
- NEVER place a bottle of lidocaine or
keep a cell phone in your pants pocket. Info at
www.philipleonard.com and
www.thankyoudrleonard.com
Transcripts from TSMBE
Temporary Suspension Hearing
- Dr. Pat Herrera - An Alabama
physician receives an inquiry on his prescriptions for pain killers from an
insurance company, at the same time that two teenagers (who had no
relationship to Dr Herrera) die of an overdose. A media feeding frenzy
results. The state board shows it's muscle by revoking Herrera's license.
A
judge has demanded reinstatement...but the board has not given up...his
can practice medicine can't write prescriptions!
Link to his old website.
2012 update
- his license has been reinstated and he has chosen to alter the
focus of his
practice to a different specialty. Subtle retaliation
continue.
- Dr. Lorraine Martinez - a temporary hospital
suspension escalates out of control for a New Mexico
obstetrician/gynecologist. 2012 update - she moved to a different state and
has a successful practice there.
-
Lydia Grotti,
MD- 8/22/2003 Temporary Win!
(Follow Link for story)
Details of
her case the fight continues
- Laura Crafton, MD - Dr Crafton was
Shammed Peer Reviewed when she had a contract dispute with the Hospital. Laura
was particularly well loved as she ministered to the spiritual needs of her
patients as well. Dr Crafton has never been sued for malpractice in her
entire long career!! Dr Crafton's name is included in the National
Practitioner Data Bank and can no longer practice Medicine. Think
Laura is a "Bad Doc"? Please read on...
Due process is often ignored. A
multitude of careers and lives have been destroyed by the abuse
of the system.
-
Robert Weitzel, MD,
Psychiatrist - Utah pain physician charged with
murder;
When he asked, Dr. Weitzel was told he was being investigated
because he was "a psychiatrist prescribing opiates".
follow link for his website
Featured in 60 minutes
-
Dr James Thompson -
HCA whistleblower
- Annelle Blanchard, MD, Peer Reviewed To Death !!
- Dr Ron Virmani - a
OB-GYN claims he faced racial discrimination in the peer review process and
can't have access to 20 years of peer review records to prove his case.
- Clive Sinoff M.D
- an oncologist in Cleveland, Ohio. Even now, Dr. Sinoff is wading through the mine field of
"peer review."
- Roland Chalifoux,MD, - Dallas Texas, Neurosurgeon
Featured in Due Process or Personal Assassination
- more info in the Members only section
- Robert J. Sinaiko, M.D
- under investigation and prosecution by the California Medical Board, primarily because they challenge
his right to engage in decisions about care grounded in clinical experience, academic research and framed by a thorough informed consent
procedure. At the heart of their complaint was his use of the allergy treatment approach now widely preferred in England, Enzyme
Potentiated Desensitization (EPD). While safer, more effective, more efficient and ultimately more economical, the Medical Board
challenged my right as an allergist to have access to this treatment.
- Dr David Odom - Fairbanks, Alaska anesthesiologist-
won in the courts in April but the hospital continues to fight back...( complaints began when he started to form a free-standing outpatient surgical
center.)
- Dr Lawrence Bailey
- Dr Nancy Lynn Rogers -
Louisiana neurosurgeon feels like she's caught in a Dukes of Hazard episode-
unfortunately it's real! - she was told that she cannot practice at the
local community hospital because she was a disruptive bitch.
She faced gender discrimination issues.
- Dr. Margaret
Nordell
- Dr. Carl Bernofsky -
Tulane's discrimination, defamation, and retaliation Against
Jewish Professor of Medicine Asserted in wrongful termination and
subsequent lawsuits
- Dr. Sundar Nilavar -
"My only
crime was being very vocal advocate of quality issues in patient care and refuse
to dance to the tune of Administration, I told them orally & in writing that I will try to
do the best I can to my patients (as if they are my family) without regard to
interest of Hosp Administration or HMOs or any other bottom line oriented pencil pushers!"
- Dr. Martin Goldman
-Jackson County Circuit Judge John Moran found that the hospital denied due
process to Dr. Martin Goldman, the head of Truman's radiology department, when
it sought to remove him in December 1997.
- Bahram Zamanian, M.D
-
cardiologist in New Orleans, LA. Note the discussion of bad faith peer review and the
law in the legal opinion from the circuit court of appeals.
- John Minarcik, MD
- a Florida pathologist who was jumped on by a large hospital chain. Even though the courts
backed him, the hospital just won't quit!
- David A. Shaller, M.D.
contested his dismissal from the
Veterans Administration after he protested substandard care of patients on
ventilators by persons untrained in same.
-
Dr. Stephen W. Smith, US Army
- Stephen Smith took on the entire Army. And even
though he "won" they continue to take potshots. For detailed info visit
his website.
- Tai-Min Chen MD -
Suspension; Fort Wayne, IN
April 27, 2000
- P.V. Patel, MD - Midland, Texas
cardiologist
- Dr Patton
- Dr Conner (California)
-Conner was denied reappointment to Salina following a peer review panel
recommended against the reappointment. The district court said it was private
and there were no federal grounds
- Pankaj Desai, MD - New York plastic surgeon decided to expand his practice; competition went
into attack mode
- More Tales of bad faith or
"sham" peer review
- growing list...EPIDEMIC
-
"Peer Review Can Be
Deadly"
|
New sub-committees are being formed:
- OB - GYN's - most common peer reviewed
- General Surgery - 2nd most common
peer reviewed
- Pain Specialists and Pain Clinics -
Pain
Issues
- Geographical issues - a number of state medical
boards are on the warpath - we have battle experience in many
states including Texas, California, Arizona, North Dakota,
Alabama, Louisiana, Alabama among others....
- Discriminatory Issues from healthcare regulation - if
a medical practitioner does not follow every mandated
regulation, not only will he/she not get paid but may have their
license suspended.
if you are interested in joining
any of these, email your interest to
info@peerreview.org
|
|
 Members ONLY
Access OUR Resources-
Network with Fellow Victims of Sham Peer Review
The FIRST
thing to do when Sham Peer Reviewed,
Summary Suspended or
when you get a Letter from your State Medical Board
 Health
Links Select Site |
|
CPRJ
2340 Belle Chasse
Highway
Suite 100
Gretna, Louisiana 70056
we do
not accept mail at this location |
|
Peer Review Solutions
www.PeerReviewSolutions.org
Richard's articles, "thank you" notes and testimonials are
included in our newest website. |
|
|
|
Want
Your own Website?
 |
|
|
|
Civil
litigation is not for everyone, but Dr.
Willner has successfully kept physicians
employed – even when facing seemingly
hopeless odds.